A thrilling novel about humans, angels, and immortals, Breath of Angel is an interesting addition to the ranks of fantasy work by Christian authors. From the start, I knew that humans and angels had to work together to restore the stairway to Heaven, so I was interested in seeing how a publishing company focused on Christian literature would tackle the theological quagmire sure to erupt in Breath of Angel. The short answer is—they didn’t.
The plot itself revolves around Melaia, a young priestess whose life is thrown into chaos when a winged angel falls into the courtyard temple and dies in front of her. Suddenly, all the mythical stories Melaia has heard about angels turn out to be true—angels do exist. Since the stairway to heaven was destroyed, many angels have become earthbound, choosing to live with, and in some cases, marry humans. Melaia learns that it is her duty to restore this staircase by breath of angel and blood of man as she tries to navigate the world of angels, figure out her romantic feelings for a certain someone, and save the day. The first in the Angeleon Circle series, Breath of Angel has a steady plot line that doesn’t disappoint.
While I immensely enjoyed Breath of Angel, I feel confused. I know what the Bible tells me about angels, what I’ve learned from pastors and theologians, and even researched the mysterious “Nephilim.” The angels in this book are nothing like the Bible’s depiction of angels. I find it disturbing when fallen angels (or angels in general) choose to live and breed with humans, creating angel/human hybrids, and a book like this encourages the idea that humans can and should fall in love with angels and that angels have an identity apart from serving God. To me, this is very dangerous.
However, Henley also invents a different world—another kingdom—in which all this plays out, so one could argue that these angels are more like elves or fairies. Therefore, perhaps the author isn’t trying to make a theological argument, just write a fantasy novel with angels, half-angels, humans, and some other creatures. But, then, why not call them elves? Or fairies? Or something else entirely? Why did Henley choose angels to be the paranormal stars in her novel?
Henley plays off Christian theology and Scripture–such as the hierarchy of angels (though she renames them), the idea that angels are in the presence of God (who she refers to as “the Most High”), the Nephilim and theory that angels or demons did marry humans at one point in history (found in the books of Genesis and Numbers), Jacob’s ladder (Jacob’s dream/vision of angels ascending and descending a ladder to Heaven), and finally, the mention in the book of Genesis that the Garden of Eden was closed to Adam and Eve and humankind so that they could not eat from the Tree of Life and become immortal. However, none of these are clearly explained mixing theology and imagination in a way that could be damaging to young Christians, who may incorrectly believe these fantastical renderings to be Scriptural truths about angels. Also, I believe this promotes an unhealthy interest in angelology and the unhealthy worship of angels themselves.
Here are a few of the renderings of angels that bother me in light of the authority of the Bible:
1. Angels control the elements appearing as wind, fire, and so forth. This seems to be a misrepresentation of God appearing as a cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night when leading the Israelites out of Egypt. He also appeared to the prophet, Elijah, as a “gentle whisper.”
2. Humans and angels are friends. Never in Scripture does this happen; angels seem to serve a purpose, send a message, and then are on their way. Angels do spend time at Lot’s house and save his family from the destruction of Sodom and Gommorah, but that’s about it. (Unless you include the references in the New Testament in which Jesus was ministered to by angels after his 40 days in the desert.)
3. Humans and angels are more than friends. Again, we come back to the Nephilim–referenced in Genesis and Numbers, but no one really understands who or what the Nephilim are. The Bible says that in heaven we will be like angels who do not marry. This is problematic when considering the marriages and offspring between angels, angels and humans, as well as angels and immortals. There is no evidence that offspring from these unions is possible or even probable given that humans and angels are different creatures with different purposes. From my understanding of Scripture, angels are genderless (though only appearing as men to humans in the Bible) and do not reproduce.
4. Angels do things other than serving God. Nowhere do angels do anything but serve God, except for Satan and the fallen angels, who refuse to serve God.
5. The malevolents or “bad angels” are at the bidding of an immortal human. This gives humans way too much power. Perhaps it will come out later in the series that the malevolents are secretly using the humans to wage war against the vaguely mentioned “Most High,” but that doesn’t seem to be the case in the first book of the series. Demons are kept in check by God, but can very much affect humans as seen in the book of Job as well as the references to the demoniacs in the Gospels.
Other than these gaping theological issues, Breath of Angel is a good read—one I would gladly recommend if Henley has chosen to use something but angels. I am just unsettled by this author’s depiction of angels, find it contradictory to the Bible, and cannot endorse this book.
*The following contains more information on Breath of Angel, including the book’s first chapter. Read on and decide for yourself if Breath of Angel is for you.*
It is time for a FIRST Wild Card Tour book review! If you wish to join the FIRST blog alliance, just click the button. We are a group of reviewers who tour Christian books. A Wild Card post includes a brief bio of the author and a full chapter from each book toured. The reason it is called a FIRST Wild Card Tour is that you never know if the book will be fiction, non~fiction, for young, or for old…or for somewhere in between! Enjoy your free peek into the book!
You never know when I might play a wild card on you!
and the book:
WaterBrook Press (June 21, 2011)
***Special thanks to Lynette Kittle, Senior Publicist, WaterBrook Multnomah, a Division of Random House for sending me a review copy.***
Karyn Henley has written over 100 titles, along with being an accomplished songwriter nominated for a Dove Award. She also received a regional Emmy Award as Music Composer for a television special and lives in Nashville, Tennessee with her husband, a jazz drummer.
Visit the author’s website.
In Breath of Angel (WaterBrook Press, June 21, 2011), award winning author Karyn Henley brings to life the tale of Melaia, a young priestess who witnesses the murder of a stranger in the temple courtyard. A place where age-old legends recited in song suddenly come to life, in this story of two immortal brothers quest for restoration.
With Angels. Shape-shifters. Myths and stories… Melaia finds herself in the middle of a blood feud between two immortal brothers who destroyed the stairway to heaven, stranding angels in the earthly realm.
Young readers are sure to be intrigued and dig deeper into this make-believe story that explores the payment for redemption.
List Price: $9.99
Reading level: Young Adult
Paperback: 272 pages
Publisher: WaterBrook Press (June 21, 2011)
AND NOW…THE FIRST CHAPTER:
The prick of the thorn drew blood, but Melaia smiled. The last ramble rose of the season was well worth a pierced thumb. She carefully drew the blossom from the vine that clung to the side of the temple. As she breathed its rich, sweet scent, she sensed someone watching and looked up, expecting to see one of the novice priestesses. She saw only dry leaves skittering across the flagstones of the walled courtyard, along with a black feather, no doubt from a bird scavenging seeds in the woodpile.
Then a haggard young man stepped through the gate, and Melaia drew back. The chill autumn breeze riffled the edge of his dirt-stained cloak, revealing the corner of a journey pack and the hilt of a dagger. Melaia gave him a tentative nod.
“I’ve come—” His voice was dirt dry. He wiped his fist across his mouth.
“I’ll fetch water.” Melaia tucked the rose into her waist sash and headed for the stone urn by the arched doorway. “Travelers are always welcome at our temple. We’ve pallets if you wish to stay the night.” She would have to check with the high priestess, but Hanni rarely turned away weary travelers.
“My thanks,” the man croaked.
Melaia flipped back her loose honey brown braid and dipped a pottery cup into the cool water. “I’m chantress here, always eager to hear new tales from travelers.”
The young man looked too weary to tell tales. Or too ill. His dark-ringed eyes darted from one afternoon shadow to another, and he cocked his head as if he heard something beyond the walls.
“We’re healers here as well,” she offered.
For a moment his wild eyes focused on her. Then he glanced above her head, and his hand went to his dagger.
But he never drew it.
A hawk, larger than any she’d ever seen, shot like an arrow past Melaia and sank its talons into the stranger’s chest. The man’s raw screams pierced the air as the hawk’s beak knifed at his throat.
Melaia stood stunned and speechless. But as the hawk flapped its great wings and lifted the man a handbreadth off the flagstones, her senses surged back.
She snatched a branch from the woodpile and swung it at the hawk. The raptor screeched and dropped the stranger. “Fight!” she yelled at him. “Fight back!”
But it was the hawk that fought, its wings beating at her stick as its claws snagged the man again. At last Melaia struck a solid blow to the hawk’s head, and it skidded sideways. She chased after it, but the raptor took to the air, quickly rose, and soared away over the domed roof of the temple.
Melaia flung aside the stick and fell to her knees by the bloodied man. Then she covered her mouth and swallowed a bitter taste. “Most High, have mercy,” she croaked. Seeing wounds so deep and blood flowing freely, she wasn’t surprised that the stranger’s mistlike spirit had emerged from his body.
As a death-prophet, she could see the shadowy echo writhing around his form as he struggled to live.
“Mellie? Is it safe?” Dark-eyed Iona stood in the temple doorway, holding back the other two novices. At fourteen, she was the motherly one, although Melaia was two years older. Curly-haired Peron, still baby plump at six, peered around Iona, clutching her skirts, while twelve-year-old Nuri broke away from them and ran across the yard, her usual dimpled smile gone.
“Is he dead?” Nuri asked.
“Not yet,” Melaia told her. “Take Peron and fetch a basket of plumwort. And water.”
Nuri stared at the man’s wounds. “We saw the hawk.”
“Go!” said Melaia. “I need plumwort to stanch the bleeding.”
As Nuri dashed away, Melaia wondered why the high priestess hadn’t appeared.
“Where’s Hanni?” she called to Iona.
“Summoned to a birthing. The weaver’s wife.” Iona nervously twisted the end of her black braid.
“Then come help me carry the man inside.”
Melaia hesitated. She was often called to the bedside of the dying to confirm the moment of death, but never had she been required to reach through a spirit to touch someone. Of course, other people did it all the time, she told herself. They just couldn’t see the struggling, mistlike layer. She took a deep breath, grasped the man’s bloodied cloak, and pressed it to the gashes in his chest. His spirit pooled around her wrists, vibrating like a throat quivering with speech.
“Can you hear me?” Melaia asked, keeping pressure on his wound. The stranger’s spirit thrummed frantically, as if he were trying to say something.
“Where’s the plumwort?” Melaia yelled.
Nuri ran across the yard, sloshing a jar of water. Peron trotted behind her with the basket of plumwort. Iona knelt at the man’s feet, her mouth moving silently in prayer.
Melaia reached for the plumwort, but the man’s spirit slid off his body, thinned into a stream, and seeped through a crack in the flagstones. A sudden, grim silence fell over the yard. Melaia shook her head at Nuri and Peron and closed the man’s green-flecked eyes.
Peron stuck out her lower lip. “I was too slow.”
“No, I was.” Nuri’s shoulders drooped.
“No one’s at fault,” said Melaia, but she couldn’t help thinking that the man might still be alive if she had only laid into the hawk sooner. “Let’s get him inside.” She lifted his upper body. For his bulk he was surprisingly light.
Iona lifted his legs. “Starved twig-thin,” she said. “Poor man.”
They carried the stranger to the sanctuary altar, the bier for those who
could afford no better. Melaia took a deep breath, wishing Hanni were there.
“Iona, find me a winding-sheet,” she said. “Peron, go with Nuri. Fetch more
water and scrub the courtyard.”
“But it’s bloody,” said Nuri. Peron wrinkled her nose.
“Would you rather clean the man’s body?” asked Melaia. Nuri and Peron
scrambled out the door. Iona followed.
Melaia gently eased the man’s cloak from his chest and winced, wondering where Hanni would begin. She exhaled slowly. “Start with the easiest,” she murmured.
She untangled his pack from one forearm. As she slipped it free, she noticed the end of a small scroll clenched in his fist. “First the pack,” she told herself, glancing around. Her gaze fell on a shelf of incense bowls. She stashed the pack there, then turned back to the altar-bier and froze.
The stranger’s cloak had fallen back and, with it, a long, white, bloodstained wing.
Melaia’s knees almost buckled. “An angel?” she whispered. It couldn’t be. Angels were found only in legends. Chanters’ stories. Bedtime tales.
Iona’s voice echoed down the corridor. “Do we need more water?”
Melaia jerked the cloak back around the man.
Iona strode in with a bundle of white linen. “Do we need more water?”
“We need Hanni,” said Melaia.
“You look as if you’ve seen the man’s ghost.” Iona looked around. “Has he
“Just go get Hanni.”
Distant drums signaled the closing of Navia’s city gates and the change of watch on the walls. On the altar-bier in the temple, the winged man lay serene and clean, covered in white linen up to his chin. Melaia didn’t often sit with the dead, but as she lit the oil lamps behind the bier, she decided that tonight she would request a vigil. She hoped the high priestess would join her, for she had a night’s worth of questions to ask.
But so far, the high priestess hadn’t returned. She had sent Iona back to say
that the birthing was a difficult one and she must stay with it, although she was upset at the news of a death in the side yard. Hanni intended to stop by the overlord’s villa and bring his advisor, Benasin, back to the temple with her.
As Melaia held the flaming twist of rushweed to the last wick, she eyed the three girls munching their supper on a reed mat across the room. With Hanni gone they had asked to stay with Melaia instead of eating in the hearthroom down the hall. She was glad for their company. She felt as shaky as they did, although she hadn’t told them about the stranger’s wings. She wanted Hanni’s opinion first.
Melaia tossed the spent rushweed into the brazier in the center of the room and stirred the coals into flame. For a moment she watched the smoke curl up and drift like a dying spirit out through the roof hole above. Except dying spirits always drifted down, not up.
“I’m saving my scraps for the chee-dees,” Peron said, scooping her crumbs into a tiny hill.
“Fetch your crumb jar from the storeroom, then,” said Melaia. “When you’ve finished cleaning up, I’ll tell a story.”
Peron stared warily at the dark corridor that lay beyond the bier.
“I’ll go with you.” Nuri slipped one of the lamps from its niche. With an uneasy smile she guided Peron to the corridor, giving wide berth to the bier.
Iona stoppered the olive oil. “Peron is telling tales again. This time it’s about two falcons scaring away her songbird friends.”
“She must have been inspired by the hawk in the yard today.” Melaia stacked the empty wooden bowls and glanced at the stranger who should have eaten a meal with them tonight.
“Peron said the falcons were darker than closed eyes,” said Iona. “I can picture that.” Melaia lifted her harp from its peg.
“And they had people hands.” Iona rolled her eyes.
“That I can’t picture,” said Melaia. “Too ghoulish.”
Iona laughed. “With such an imagination Peron will surely become a chantress.”
A shriek came from the corridor. Peron darted into the room, hugging her crumb jar, with Nuri on her heels. Both girls were open-mouthed and wide-eyed.
Behind them limped a sharp-nosed, beardless man wearing a cloak fashioned
completely of feathers—brown, black, and an iridescent blue that glinted in the lamplight. The skin around one of his round gold eyes was blackened, and a scratch jagged across his brow.
Melaia went cold, head to toe. How had the man entered? Had she left the side door unbolted?
Nuri and Peron ran to Iona, and all three huddled by the wall. Melaia stifled her impulse to join them. Hanni had left her in charge, so in charge she would be. She had fought off a murdering hawk. She had prepared a bloody winged man for burial. She would stand up to this intruder.
She strode to the brazier, her hands clammy as she clung to her harp. “This is the temple of the Most High,” she said, hoping he wouldn’t hear the quaver in her voice.
“So it is,” he hissed, limping to the bier. “I believe I noticed that.” “What’s your business here?”
He raised an eyebrow. “Surely you’re not the high priestess.”
“She’s the chantress,” blurted Peron.
“Ah. Singer of songs, soother of sorrows,” he crooned.
“If you’re here for our treasury box, take it and be on your way,” said Melaia.
“I have unfinished business with the high priestess,” he said.
“You can find her at the overlord’s villa,” said Melaia.
“No doubt.” With a gloved hand he slid back the sheet that covered the corpse. He smiled at the gashes, then studied Melaia. “Chantress, play your harp for me.”
Melaia gaped at him. “You have no right—”
“Or let me play it,” he said. “The little girl can bring it. The one who feeds the birds.”
Peron’s eyes grew round as the supper bowls, and she shrank behind Iona’s skirts.
Melaia hugged the harp tighter to her chest and glared at the man defiantly, even as she fought back a fear that curdled in the pit of her stomach. How long had this swaggerer been spying on them?
His unblinking gold eyes stared back at her. “I do not take disobedience lightly.” His voice was ice. “Send the girl with the harp or play it yourself.”
Melaia swallowed dryly. She felt her courage fall as limp as the poor stranger in the yard. Keeping her eyes on the intruder, she sank to a bench by the brazier and positioned the harp in her lap.
“Let us hear the tale of the Wisdom Tree,” he said. “You know it, don’t you, Chantress?”
Melaia scowled at him and motioned for the girls to join her. As she fingered
the melody, they silently gathered around, and she breathed easier. Together they were safer, with the brazier as a barrier between them and the bully.
She turned her attention back to the harp, and over the music she spoke the tale.
In a time long ago, there lived a tribal chieftain whose firstborn son was
a wealthy trader, his second-born a lone hunter. Each year at harvest festival, his sons vied to present him with the best gift. The Firstborn always gave perfumes, musicians, slave dancers, the treasures of his trade. The Second-born presented partridges, deerskins, lion-claw necklaces, the spoils of the hunt. But the Second-born thought his gifts paltry compared to those of the Firstborn. So he set out to seek the greatest gift of all.
Far and wide he journeyed, to no avail. At last, weary and discouraged, he lay to rest in the shade of a tree as tall and wide as the tower of a citadel. The Wisdom Tree it was, bearing fruit that granted the eater knowledge and cleverness.
Peron popped her thumb out of her mouth and chanted, “Within this tree stood the stairway to heaven made wholly of light.”
“Exactly,” said Melaia, glad that for the moment the tale was distracting Peron from the intruder, whose gold eyes held a hungry glitter. Melaia continued:
An angel named Dreia, guardian of the Tree, saw the Second son lying there and asked the cause of his despair. When he told his tale, she pitied him and gave him the juice of one fruit. “This will grant you knowledge and cleverness to find the right gift for your father,” she said.
As he sipped the juice, the man’s eyes brightened. “I know the perfect gift,” he said. “A fruit from this Tree.”
Dreia hadn’t intended to give the man a whole fruit. Its seeds were precious, carried by angels into the heavens to plant wisdom trees in worlds among the stars. Yet the man was handsome, his entreaties eloquent.
At last Dreia said, “You may take one fruit if you vow to bring me the first creature that greets you when you arrive home. This I shall send over the stairway as payment. Moreover, you shall return the three
seeds of this fruit, for they are strictly forbidden to mortals. Should you fail to repay your debt, the Tree itself shall exact payment in breath and blood.”
The Second-born agreed to the bargain, for the one who always greeted his homecoming was his old hunting dog. Taking his dog and the seeds back to Dreia would be good reason to see the beautiful angel again. So he carried the fruit home.
While he was still afar off, he saw, bounding across the field to greet him, his young niece. “Uncle!” she cried. “Terrible news. Your old hunting dog has died.”
The Second-born fell to his knees and wept, not for his dog, but for his niece, the only daughter of the Firstborn, now to be payment for his debt.
Melaia paused as the intruder slipped off his gloves. His fingernails were long, curved, and sharp. Talons. Her pulse pounded at her throat. His blackened eye, his scratched brow, his feathered cloak, his limp.
She had met him before. As a hawk.
“Is there no ending to the tale?” He smirked at her recognition of him and stroked the corpse. “I favor endings.”
Melaia felt foggy, as if she were in a dream. She tried to gather her thoughts.
“The Second-born knew only one way to escape his debt,” Iona prompted.
“Yes.” Melaia cleared her throat and forced out the words.
The Second-born knew he had to destroy the Wisdom Tree.
Dreia saw an army approaching, the Second son in the lead, betrayal in his heart. She gathered what angels she could. Some plucked the remaining fruit and hastened over the stairway to celestial worlds.
Others stayed behind to defend the Tree. But these were not warring angels. The best they could do was save some of the wood as the Tree fell and was plundered by men who wanted pieces for themselves.
“That was the end of the stairway,” Nuri said.
“And the end of angels in our world,” added Iona.
“But the brothers planted the seeds of the Wisdom Tree,” offered Peron,
“They did.” Melaia set the harp aside. “The brothers learned that cultivating wisdom takes patience.”
The girls chimed in, “Wisdom, over time, is earned.”
The hawkman hissed. “A pitiful ending and woefully false.” He pointed a taloned finger at Melaia. “Remember this, Chantress. The Second-born abducted his niece and headed for Dreia. But fortune was with the Firstborn, for
I discovered the treachery in time to rescue my daughter. To ensure that the Tree never collected on the debt, I destroyed it. My daughter and I ate the seeds, round and shiny, red as blood. We became immortal!”
“You’re trying to haunt us with our own tale.” Melaia took up a poker and stabbed the coals in the brazier, determined not to show her fear. “There were three seeds.”
“So there were,” said the hawkman. “The third I crammed down my brother’s throat. Now he owes his debt for all eternity. And it is my pleasure to make sure he never repays.” He grinned at the dead man. “Son of Dreia, this night you are destroyed.”
He snatched up the corpse, and its wings unfolded. The girls shrieked and ran to Melaia.
The hawkman dropped the body back to the bier as if it had burned him.
Then he cursed and shoved it to the floor. He scanned the room. “The man
had a pack. Where is it?”
“Maybe he lost it in the side yard.” Melaia felt her face grow warm at the half lie.
But the man didn’t press his search. Instead, he stiffened and stared at the front door, his head cocked, listening. Melaia heard only wind, but the hawkman slowly retreated, tense as a cat backing away from danger. He glanced from the door to the window to the roof hole, where smoke drifted into the night. Then he hurtled toward the brazier, and his body contorted.
All of Melaia’s instincts screamed at her to run, but she stayed her feet, clenched her jaw, and gripped the poker with both hands. As the hawk leaped into the flames, she swung with all her might.
She struck only air as he rose in the smoke and vanished.
4 thoughts on “FIRST Wild Card Tour + Review: Breath of Angel by Karyn Henley”
You write this review pretty well. I wouldn’t be able to do it. It sounds too supernatural (judging from the 1st chapter) and it seems to conflict with the Bible in quite a number of places.
Thanks, Evangeline! I appreciate it! 🙂
Why must we as Christians follow the world’s leading into these supernatural demonic areas? The world belongs to Satan and he is laughing at us. Let us take the lead back to what is pure and just and holy – God’s side.The YA market is more important to supposedly Christian publishers than being true to God’s Word?
I forgot to mention – great job, Amy, for standing firm on the Word. I’m proud of you, once again!